Criminal Defense Mitigation Investigation
Experienced, compassionate investigation for capital cases, juvenile resentencing, and non-capital sentencing matters. Donna Murray works alongside defense attorneys to uncover, document, and clearly present the life history behind every client and case.
More than 20 years of investigative experience | Florida Licensed Private Investigator | Capital and resentencing experience
(239) 810-3666
Agency License #A1400174
Hear Donna discuss her approach to mitigation investigation
Donna Murray Featured on A&E’s Kids Behind Bars: Life or Parole, 2019
More Than the Charges. The Full Story of the Client.
Every client has a life history that cannot be understood through police reports, court records, or the alleged offense alone.
Murray Investigations and Mitigation Specialists works with criminal defense attorneys and legal teams to uncover the experiences and circumstances that shaped the client’s life. Through comprehensive record collection, in-depth interviews, social-history investigation, timelines, genograms, and expert coordination, Donna Murray helps the defense team develop a complete, accurate, and human-centered mitigation narrative.
The work is detailed. The subject matter is often sensitive. Every investigation is approached with compassion, objectivity, persistence, and respect for the client and the defense team.
Mitigation Services for Criminal Defense Teams
Capital and Death Penalty Mitigation
Comprehensive life-history and social-history investigation for clients facing the possibility of a death sentence. Donna gathers records, conducts interviews, develops timelines and genograms, identifies mitigating factors, and assists the defense team with expert coordination.
Juvenile Resentencing Mitigation
Detailed investigation into childhood development, family environment, trauma, mental and behavioral health, institutional history, maturity, rehabilitation, and the client’s growth over time.
Non-Capital Sentence Mitigation
Fact-supported investigation that helps defense counsel present a fuller understanding of the client during sentencing, plea negotiations, downward-departure considerations, and other appropriate proceedings.
Experience That Strengthens the Defense Team
Donna L. Murray, M.A., L.P.I., is a mitigation specialist and licensed private investigator with more than 20 years of experience. She has conducted hundreds of criminal defense investigations and worked on more than 70 Florida capital and resentencing cases.
Her experience extends beyond Florida to cases in Puerto Rico, Kentucky, and Mississippi. Donna previously served as Chief Investigator for the Office of the Public Defender in Lee County, Florida, where she was recognized as part of the team receiving the Prudential Davis Productivity Award for in-house mitigation.
Her combination of investigative experience, forensic interviewing, social-history development, and ability to build trust with clients makes her a valuable and collaborative member of the defense team.
- 20+ Years of Experience
Conducting criminal defense and mitigation investigations. - 70+ Capital and Resentencing Cases
Extensive work involving complex, high-stakes matters. - Hundreds of Defense Investigations
Experience uncovering and organizing case-critical information. - Multistate and International Work
Cases and field investigations extending beyond Florida.
Building a Complete Life-History Investigation
Depending on the case, the investigation may explore:
- Family and multigenerational history
- Childhood development and home environment
- Trauma, abuse, neglect, and instability
- Medical and mental health history
- Education and intellectual development
- Substance use and treatment history
- Employment and military service
- Community relationships and support systems
- Incarceration, institutional history, and rehabilitation
- Cultural, social, and environmental influences
These facts are carefully documented, organized, and developed into a mitigation narrative that helps counsel present the client as a complete human being.
A Thorough and Collaborative Process
Investigate
Records are identified and reviewed, and the people who know the client’s history are located and interviewed.
Understand
Patterns, experiences, relationships, and mitigating factors are examined within the context of the client’s development.
Document
Timelines, genograms, social histories, records, and interview findings are organized for the defense team.
Humanize
The information is developed into a credible narrative that helps counsel communicate the client’s complete life story.
Experience
Over 20 years of experience as an investigator and has conducted hundreds of criminal defense investigations.
Education
Donna earned her Master of Arts in Criminal Justice Administration from the University of South Florida. Additionally, she is certified through Florida Gulf Coast University as a Forensic Interviewer and Interrogator where she enhanced her highly skilled interviewing techniques.
Accomplishments
Donna previously worked as Chief Investigator at the Office of the Public Defender in Lee County, Florida where she was recognized with the team Prudential Davis Productivity Award for in-house mitigation. Awarded “Outstanding Citizen of the Year” by NASW for her work mentoring and developing social work interns from FGCU.
Mitigation Specialist
Donna has worked on more than 70 Florida capital and resentencing cases. She has also worked on cases in Puerto Rico, Kentucky and Mississippi. Her mitigation work has contributed to defense efforts in cases where the death penalty was waived and in capital trials resulting in life verdicts. Several of her cases have gone through trial resulting in life verdicts. She has assisted counsel with the death qualification process during numerous capital trials.
Expert Witnesses
Identifying appropriate experts is a critical part of the case. Donna will recommend to the team which expert is best for each individual case and personally introduce them to the client to facilitate positive client cooperation and trust.
Affiliations
Donna is a member of FACDL, NACDL, NASAMS, Advocacy and Support Group; American Society of Criminology, Corrections and Sentencing Division; National Association for Public Defense; and NDIA.
Need more information on Donna Murray or would like to schedule a consultation
Who hires Murray Investigations?
Murray Investigations works with criminal defense attorneys, public defender offices, court-appointed counsel, and other members of criminal defense teams.
What types of cases does Donna Murray accept?
Donna provides mitigation investigation for capital and death penalty cases, juvenile resentencing matters, and appropriate non-capital sentencing cases.
Where does Murray Investigations accept cases?
Murray Investigations is based in Florida and has experience working on cases in Florida and other jurisdictions. Availability depends on the location, timing, and scope of the case.
How early should a mitigation specialist become involved?
Early involvement generally provides more time to locate records, identify witnesses, establish trust with the client and family, and investigate the client’s history thoroughly. Counsel should contact Donna to discuss the circumstances and schedule of the case.
2026 Copyright by Murray Investigations and Mitigation Specialists. All rights reserved. Website by Visitivity Inc.